The ex-CJI pointed out that regional parties have done phenomenally well in recent times and are now ruling most of the states. Former Chief Justice DY Chandrachud has dismissed speculation about India becoming a “one-party” nation under the Bharatiya Janata Party-led Centre, quoting the 2024 Lok Sabha election mandate.
While on an interview for BBC’s Hardtalk with Stephen Sackur, the retired Chief Justice of India was inquired if he ever encountered political pressure from the government in his time in office. The former Chief Justice was quoted mentioning a New York Times editorial on how India is turning into a “one-party state,” and the ruling party is said to be pressuring the judiciary for shielding its party members while hitting out at its political rivals, as alleged by opposition leaders.
The former CJI scoffed at the NYT article as “completely wrong” and cited the outcome of the 2024 general elections as proof of the sway of state politics and regional parties. He pointed out that regional aspirations and identities have become very much in focus in India’s states, with regional political parties doing exceptionally well and now controlling a majority of the states.
When asked about Rahul Gandhi’s conviction in a defamation case, the former Chief Justice pointed out that the Supreme Court had subsequently stayed the judgment. He explained, “Although a trial court in India had passed a verdict, the Supreme Court stayed the judgment, allowing the political leader in question to resume his activities in Parliament.”
The then CJI also stressed that Indian courts have been steadfast in maintaining personal freedoms, pointing to a series of examples where bail had been granted. “The higher courts, the Supreme Court among them, have made it explicit that we are here to guard personal liberties. Though there will be disagreement over individual cases, the Supreme Court has led the way in preserving personal freedom, and that’s why the people have faith in us,” he added.
